Thanksgiving—a day that evokes images of bountiful feasts, family gatherings, and football games. It’s a holiday steeped in tradition, yet not without its controversies. For some, it is a cherished time to express gratitude, while for others, it is a painful reminder of historical injustices. Let’s explore the multifaceted nature of this holiday, from the joyous to the somber, with a touch of sarcasm and heartfelt reflection.

The Joyful Gatherings

For many, Thanksgiving is a time to gather with loved ones and indulge in a feast that could rival any culinary celebration. The centerpiece? A golden-brown turkey, of course! Accompanied by creamy mashed potatoes, roasted veggies, macaroni and cheese that oozes with cheesy goodness, string beans, collards, and fresh salads—it’s a spread that leaves no room for modesty. As Nora Ephron aptly put it, “The turkey. The sweet potatoes. The stuffing. The pumpkin pie. Is there anything else we all can agree so vehemently about? I don’t think so”.

And let’s not forget the beverages—beer, wine, cocktails, and for those who like a bit more kick, rum punch or sorrel laced with Ray & Nephew’s white rum. It’s a time when even the most reserved family members might find themselves loosening up after a few sips.

The Great Debate: To Celebrate or Not?

While many Americans embrace Thanksgiving as a day of gratitude and togetherness, others view it through a more critical lens. The holiday’s origins are mired in controversy due to the often romanticized narrative of Pilgrims and Native Americans sharing a harmonious meal. In reality, the history is far more complex and fraught with conflict and cultural appropriation.

For some Native Americans, Thanksgiving is seen as a “National Day of Mourning,” highlighting the colonization and subsequent suffering endured by their ancestors. As Professor Robert Jensen suggested, perhaps it’s time for a “National Day of Atonement” instead. This perspective reminds us that while we celebrate abundance, we must also acknowledge the historical context that shadows this holiday.

Football: The Unofficial Thanksgiving Sport

Thanksgiving wouldn’t be complete without football—a tradition as ingrained as pumpkin pie. From high school rivalries to NFL showdowns featuring the Chicago Bears and Detroit Lions, football games have become synonymous with Thanksgiving Day. It’s an occasion where fans gather around the TV, plates in hand, ready to cheer—or jeer—their favorite teams.

The games offer a welcome distraction from family debates over politics or who makes the best gravy. And let’s face it; there’s always that one uncle who falls asleep on the couch before halftime.

Food Coma: A Thanksgiving Tradition

Ah, the post-meal slump—an inevitable part of Thanksgiving. After indulging in copious amounts of food and drink, many find themselves succumbing to the infamous “food coma.” It’s almost as if turkey has magical powers to induce sleep (or maybe it’s just the tryptophan).

As you watch family members nod off one by one like dominoes falling in slow motion, you can’t help but chuckle at the predictability of it all. Yet amidst the snores and groans of overstuffed bellies lies a sense of contentment—a testament to a meal well-enjoyed.

A Personal Reflection on Gratitude

While Thanksgiving is traditionally celebrated on one day each year, many believe in practicing gratitude daily. As Johannes A. Gaertner said, “To speak gratitude is courteous and pleasant… but to live gratitude is to touch Heaven”. For those who cherish everyday moments with friends and family over grand celebrations, this sentiment resonates deeply.

Cooking for loved ones doesn’t need to be reserved for holidays alone. Whether it’s a weekly dinner or an impromptu gathering over takeout pizza (with extra cheese), these moments are what truly matter. After all, gratitude isn’t confined to turkey dinners; it’s found in every shared laugh and heartfelt conversation.

Thanksgiving is more than just a holiday; it’s an opportunity for reflection on both personal blessings and historical truths. It’s about finding balance between celebration and contemplation—embracing joy while acknowledging past injustices.

So whether you’re feasting on turkey or enjoying quiet moments with loved ones throughout the year—remember that gratitude knows no season. As Robert Caspar Lintner wisely noted: “Thanksgiving was never meant to be shut up in a single day”. Let us carry its spirit forward into every day we are fortunate enough to share good food and company.

May your heart be full of gratitude long after your plate is empty.

Roasted Vegetables